Is this proof animals do commit suicide like humans do? A young swan is captured apparently drowning itself after the death of its mother

I am positive animals suffer from grief, just as we do when we lose someone we love. The loss of a parent or a mate must be highly traumatizing to all life forms. However, I had always believed that suicide was pretty much the domain of humans, who tend to overreact and over-think in regards to life-altering situations. I’ve looked at multiple pictures of the swans and I noticed that the water appears to be very polluted. It is China after all, where the EPA does not rule, the state does. The swan looks matted in oil or some kind of filth from the water. The birds could also have been sick and that killed them. I suppose it could have been suicide, but it would take a tremendous override of instinct for a swan to hold their head under water until they drowned. I just don’t think that was the case.


A Chinese woman captured a young swan appearing to commit suicide after the death of its mother.

From the Daily Mail:

This is the moment a young swan apparently drowned itself in distress after the death of its mother.

Hiker Yan Yan Hsiao captured the moment the swan appeared to commit suicide.

She said she only noticed the young bird because it was making a commotion and flapping its wings in the water.

Apparently traumatised by the death of another bird, the swan stuck its head in the water, and minutes later, was also dead.

She said: ‘I looked over and saw the swan which was clearly a young animal alongside an older bird that was clearly dead.

‘She had either died because of the cold or old age but either way the young bird was very distressed.

‘After calling and flapping its wings, it then stuck its head in the water and I thought it had calmed down, but then I realised it was keeping its head in the water.

‘Minutes later, it was dead.’

She said she had been taking photographs of the swan not realising she was capturing its death at the park lake in Sanmenxia, in Central China’s Henan province.

Scientists have debated for years whether instances where an animal deliberately claims its own life because of depression can be classed as suicide

But examples date back to 1855, when the illustrated London News reported a dog had thrown itself into the water to drown and had repeated the action several times until passers-by finally allowed to sink.

There have also been numerous cases of ducks apparently drowning themselves after the death of a mate.

Illnesses such as Rabbit Fever have been known to make animals commit acts that look like suicide that are in fact a response to the illness itself. The sickness can cause a high fever and mental instability that causes erratic, suicidal-type actions. In reality, the animal is so sick, they lose their mind and go into one kind of frenzy or another before dying. That’s not to say the loss of a mate would not cause an animal to die – I believe that happens from time to time. But it is very rare. I would look to the environment and illness first. In fact, they should look into this as the cause of death is suspicious here. It is very sad to see such beautiful creatures die, however it happened.

Terresa Monroe-Hamilton

Terresa Monroe-Hamilton is an editor and writer for Right Wing News. She owns and blogs at NoisyRoom.net. She is a Constitutional Conservative and NoisyRoom focuses on political and national issues of interest to the American public. Terresa is the editor at Trevor Loudon's site, New Zeal - trevorloudon.com. She also does research at KeyWiki.org. You can email Terresa here. NoisyRoom can be found on Facebook and on Twitter.

Leave a Comment

Share this!

Enjoy reading? Share it with your friends!

Send this to a friend