For Advertising Info, Write.
rwnews@blogads.com
Premium Left blogad
Left Blog Ad

Advertisement
Ten Questions You’re Not Supposed to Ask About Islam
Written By : John Hawkins

Sometimes, when people get emotional while discussing radical Islam, they tend to paint Muslims with far too broad a brush. There are millions of decent, hard working, patriotic Muslims in this country which explains why, as late as 2000, they were voting 78% Republican.

Unfortunately, we hear from those people far too seldom while the terrorists, radical Islamist shills at CAIR, and the dirtbag building the Ground Zero Mosque seem to grab all the headlines. That makes it easy to forget that there are American Muslims out there loudly and forcefully speaking out against terrorism.

Moreover, across the world, the United States has had traditional alliances with Muslim nations, some of whom have fought side-by-side with our troops. Even in hostile nations like Iran, large numbers of Iranians held spontaneous candlelight vigils to show solidarity with America. To view Muslims like that as our enemy seems rather foolish to me.

Along similar lines, some people on the Right argue that Muslims who don’t believe in violence or jihad don’t understand their own religion. This doesn’t seem to be very…wise or helpful? Obviously, there are hundreds of millions of Muslims who don’t believe that their religion is violent. Telling them that if they understood their own religion as well as non-Muslims that they would be murdering us seems like a lose/lose sort of argument to make.

All that being said, because of political correctness and the genuine desire by the American people to be polite and tolerant, a lot of extremely important issues are simply not being discussed – and that’s a big problem.

When you refuse to talk about important topics because they make people uncomfortable, animus, distrust, and anxiety inevitably spread. On the other hand, when you have an open and honest dialogue about the real issues people debate privately, you can build comfort and trust and start to reach solutions that would never be possible in an environment where people are attacked and demonized simply for asking basic questions that most people have, but are afraid to speak out about.

So, with that in mind, here are 10 questions you’re not supposed to ask about Islam.

1) Why do so few moderate Muslims speak out against Islamic extremism? How can we get more moderate Muslims to speak up and amplify their voices?

2) Of the “moderate Muslims” who have spoken out in favor of moderation or against terrorism, a number of them have later been tied to terrorist groups or have advocated radical policies. This causes a great deal of difficulty for people who want to ally with Muslim groups because the “moderate” they’re talking to today may very well make them look bad by advocating radical policies in a month or two. What’s the best way to deal with that?

3) Because of the concept of Taqiyya, many non-Muslims believe that Muslims have few qualms about lying to non-believers. Is this a legitimate concern? If not, why not?

4) When it comes to immigration, how does the United States tell the difference between radical Islamists and moderate Muslims? If we can’t tell the difference, should that affect our immigration policies?

5) Widely accepted practices in large swathes of the Islamic world — like shariah law, honor killings, and death for apostates — are absolutely, unconditionally incompatible with western civilization. Should we be asking Muslims if they oppose those practices before we allow them to enter our country? Granted, they could lie, but the very fact that we would publicly label those customs as barbaric would send a strong signal.

6) Why does Islam have such “bloody borders?”

7) Much of the Islamic world has an extremely backward attitude toward women. Is this something that goes along with Islam or is it a cultural issue in the nations where Islam happens to have taken root?

8) Why is there so much rabid anti-Semitism in the Muslim world? Pointing to Israel doesn’t seem to be much of an answer, given that what Israel does or doesn’t do has no impact whatsoever on the day-to-day lives of 98% of the Muslim world.

9) Islam, as it’s practiced, SEEMS to be an EXTRAORDINARILY intolerant religion. Yet, non-Muslims are constantly being told we have to be tolerant to Islam. Why should non-Muslims be so tolerant of Islam when that tolerance is not being returned?

10) While there are certainly individual Muslims who seem to fit in very well in western society, Europe has had a great deal of difficulty assimilating Muslims. So, it seems natural to ask: Is Islam on a widespread scale compatible with the freedom, openness, and traditions of western civilization?

0
  • FurrowedBrow

    Top question you're not supposed to ask about GOProud:

    Why do so few gay conservative identity groups speak out against radical gay activists who want to teach first graders about gay sex and force private adoption agencies to arrange adoptions for gay couples? How can we get GOProud to speak up and amplify their voices?

    • http://www.wordaroundthenet.com Christopher Taylor

      How about:

      Why is it that a conservative group needs to identify its self by its sexual preference when that has nothing to do with the ideals or goals of conservatism?

  • President Friedman

    Great list, John. Another litmus test type question for me has to do with moderate Muslims' attitudes about Hamas. Too often, they are just downright hesitant to condemn.

    I understand that perhaps they have a bit of a nuanced view of the question, and perhaps even a little sympathy. I remain sympathetic to many of the complaints Tim McVeigh had about our government's actions at Waco and Ruby Ridge. But blowing up a building full of innocent bystanders is unequivocally wrong and he deserved to die for what he did. Period. When put to the test, you rarely hear moderate Muslims condemn Hamas for their terrorist actions, and you even more rarely hear them condemn the hardliners who boldly support Hamas's actions. And that is a problem.

  • D-Vega

    Like I said before my post disappeared, this list of questions is more what conservatives asked themselves about Islam, rather than questions that would/should/could be asked OF muslims.

    And lastly, you say in your first paragraph “Sometimes, when people get emotional while discussing radical Islam, they tend to paint Muslims with far too broad a brush.” and yet you and other here work hard to strengthen and spread that ignorance and prejudice at every opportunity, every day.

    What is the critics' responsibility in this prejudice? No where until Islam reforms itself?

    • President Friedman

      The problem is that American Muslims just aren't very culturally visible, and when they are it is usually over something controversial (Ground Zero mosque) or downright evil (Ft. Hood murders). I tend not to believe all the stereotypes because in my experience cultural stereotypes are almost always wrong or misguided, but at the same time, unlike just about every other significant ethnic, religious, or cultural group in America, I don't quite know what to think about American Muslims because I've never worked with, studied with, or been friends with any of them. The only direct experiences I've had w/ them have been over the internet at Christian apologetics forums where they were somewhat less than pleasant (and that's coming from a guy who posts to such forums as a skeptic). Certainly the media colors my opinion of Islam, but those reports don't exist in a vacuum. I remember growing up listening to Cat Stephens, and then years later seeing him on TV talking about how Salman Rushdie deserves to die. That transormation wasn't the media's fault.

      • D-Vega

        There is a disconnect I think between the muslim public persona versus their personalities.

        I have gone to school with muslims, and there are usually three general types of them:

        - Those men and women that are fully “westernized”, that is, those who embrace the American or western culture, and with that many of the liberal characteristics we celebrate, including possibly sex, drugs and alcohol. They may still pray and go to Friday Jumu'ah, but don't go to a mosque regularly. Other than those qualities, there is little difference from anyone else.

        - Those muslims who are nearly bursting (no pun intended) with western desires but still adhere to the cultural and stricter religious beliefs. These guys are usually very horny (because they can't get laid and have to wait for marraige, even an arranged marraige), the women trty to sneak around to have fun. They don't drink, but usually smoke a lot and drink lots of coffee. But they are very cool and sociable guys and gals.

        - Then there are those who are very devout. They are quiet, soft-spoken, gentlemen and ladies. They don't hang out, anywhere. They are studious, the women are very oppressed by their brothers and fathers. They seem extremely peaceful. Almost scary peaceful, I'd admit. But not violent or hateful against anyone. Except maybe Israel.

        But their public official record is usually more of the party line. Because there is a lack of trust there. That mistrust is understandable, but that in no way should mean that they should or would support people like Hamas. And that party line and mistrust gets weaker as they spend time here and embrace our way of life more.

        Muslims in the U.S. are very fine people, and have been for many decades. It's shameful that we have come to a point where we are demonizing and untrusting of them more than ever. We need to build more of a relationship with them. So both of us can stomp out the crazies, which they don't support (except for maybe some of the devout ones.)

    • http://www.wordaroundthenet.com Christopher Taylor

      Really? You think that

      “Why do so few moderate Muslims speak out against Islamic extremism? How can we get more moderate Muslims to speak up and amplify their voices?”

      is an example of a broad brush, bigotry, ignorance, and something conservatives should ask themselves about Islam?

      Really?

      Did you even read the article, or did you start out with “conservatives are Islamophobic, I read it on Talking Points Memo” and launch from there?

      • D-Vega

        Well, that previous post was a shortened version of my original one, so let me explain a bit more.

        I think better questions would be more “end game” in nature. Like, what do muslims expect to happen if Iran keeps raising the stakes in the nuclear game? What is their vision for muslims in America? Do they believe a strict interpretation of the Koran is incompatible with American society and why?

        My point is that the above questions seem to be in the context of something is wrong with Islam and how can America make it right, rather than are we misunderstanding something, and how can we better understand it in order to avoid hostility.

        It's like asking Black Americans “Why are so many blacks so quick to get on welfare rather than work?” instead of “How can the U.S. afford better opportunities for the Black community so welfare isn't necessary?”

        My comment on the rampant prejudice is not solely citing these questions, which are mild in comparison to the other stuff we see out there.

        I am referring to the consistent Islamo-bashing on this site that does indeed paint muslims with that broad brush. Some insightful questions don't negate that feed that's put into the trough regularly.

        • http://www.wordaroundthenet.com Christopher Taylor

          They might seem offensive but they are good questions – and this was hardly a broad brush; but that's what you're doing here. Presuming what John posts here is bad based on things you haven't liked by others posting in the past.

          So, you know. Kettle, pot.

          • D-Vega

            Yes, I am. But that is a separate issue.

            I think the questions could be better.

            I also think there is a a considerable amount of smearing that no one takes responsibility for.

  • UFKA_Smithwick

    Good list. I'd like for some real media outlet to hit on even one of these questions without prefacing it with “some ignorant racists are concerned with the following . . “

  • http://www.wordaroundthenet.com Christopher Taylor

    That really is a good set of questions about Islam, and they aren't the usual “I don't know anything about the religion so I'm gonna yell a bunch of stuff at those crazy guys” line of questions. Very thoughtful.

  • Jim

    Moderate Muslims dont exist. Islam is evil and was started by satan himself.

    • Esan1_2000

      So what time is the cross burning? I have to get mt robe from the cleaners.

Advertisement
Featured Video

Ed Klein on ‘The Amateur: Barack Obama in the White House’

php developer india
Premium Right Ads
Blogads Right
Previous Features

Ads

40 Of The Most Bad-Ass, Masculine, Manly, Alpha Male Quotes Of All Time
50 Things Every 18-Year-Old Should Know
Politically Correct Fairy Tales
Why Men Are Becoming Wimpy, Video Game Playing Slackers Who Don’t Want To Get Married
Horror You Will Never Get Out Of Your Brain Again: Bronies
The 10 Best Obama Ate A Dog Images From Around The Web
Advertisement
User Info