ad banner for Conservative Grapevine
Advertising Conservative Grapevine Email FAQ Home RSS Speaking Townhall YouTube
Beating liberalism to death with a shovel and a smile.



« Doubting The Iranian NIE | Main | Huckabee Tries To "Out Tancredo Tancredo" On Illegal Immigration »
December 06, 2007
John Hawkins My Initial Reaction To Mitt's Mormon Speech

I just watched all of Mitt's speech on his religion and here are my initial impressions,

* Mitt got a nice lead in from George Bush Sr., gave a generally pleasant speech, and had an enthusiastic crowd. That's a plus since it will be a heavily watched speech.

* However, the concerns that I have heard expressed about Mormonism over and over again are that it's a heretical Christian cult that has some rather strange views. Mitt didn't address those concerns at all. So, if someone had a problem with Mitt for those reasons before the speech, he probably has a problem with him after the speech as well.

* So, if Mitt didn't address the concerns people actually have about his faith, what did he do? Well, oddly enough, he sort of echoed some of the same things that Kennedy said (My church won't tell me what to do). Since that was a concern about Catholicism at the time (He might let the Pope order him around), it doesn't really seem to make sense for Mitt to discuss it.

The other thing Mitt tried to do, beyond general appeals to religious liberty, was make common cause with Christian conservatives. He said that he worshipped Jesus, just like we do, and he attempted to address a lot of the concerns that we have in general (Christianity under attack by secularism, our First Amendment rights to religious liberty being improperly taken away in the name of "separation of church and state.")

Summary: Did it help?

Well, I think he could get a bump because Mitt came across well, had a good audience, appealed to Christians, and Bush gave him a nice introduction.

On the other hand, if you were one of the people who opposed Mitt Romney because you're afraid having him as the nominee would give a boost to a heretical religion or because you think less of a guy who believes some of the weirder things that Mormons do, I'm not sure anything has changed for you since Mitt didn't address those points at all.

So, my best first guess would be that Mitt will get a temporary bump from the speech, but that it won't help him much long-term.

Rate this article:

Rating: 2.8/5 (4 votes cast)

BlinklistBlogMarksdel.icio.usDiggFurlMagnoliaNewsvineRedditStumbleuponTechnorati
    Share this article!
John Hawkins | 11:15 AM | Permalink   Comments (98)   Trackbacks (0)

Note: Comments and Trackbacks for this entry closed on December 11, 2007 11:15 AM
Most commented on recent posts
  Barack The Magic Negro's Next Trick: Killing Chip Saltsman's RNC Chair Bid (119 comments)
  The USA Isn't Going To Break-Up In 2010, But... (98 comments)
  British Bureauweenie Calls for Internet Suppression (76 comments)
  Obama, Israel, & The Muslim World (76 comments)
  The Stimulus Driven Deficit Disaster Trap (76 comments)
  NBC Cancels Coulter (68 comments)
  The 7th Annual "20 Most Annoying Liberals Of 2008" (68 comments)
  There Goes the Neighborhood (64 comments)
  Thought Of The Day: Blago, Burris, And Reid (62 comments)
  Atheists Sue to Impose Their Religion on Inauguration (59 comments)

Highest rated recent posts
  DUmmy Threads Of The Day: Those Cool French And Depleted Uranium [4.3 stars]
  The 40 Most Obnoxious Quotes For 2008 [4.2 stars]
  All The Tech In The World Won't Help You Without Enthusiastic Warm Bodies [4.2 stars]
  Death To All Juice! [4.2 stars]
  Why you're not treated like adults [4.1 stars]
  Conservative Grapevine Promo [4.1 stars]
  A Fine Little Mess [4.1 stars]
  Senator Smalley And The Republican Problem He Reveals [4.0 stars]
  Cheezy Tax Tricks: Look For New Taxes To Be Indirect And Regressive [4.0 stars]
  NBC Cancels Coulter [3.9 stars]
  You Can't Put Your Children On The Front Line And Complain When They Get Killed [3.9 stars]

ad banner for Food shortage USA
© Copyright 2001-2008 John Hawkins
eXTReMe Tracker