Silly Denials Of Islamic Terrorism Bring A Silver Lining

20
Feb, 2015
by Jonah Goldberg

“Could this argument be any dumber?”

That’s how I began a column over a month ago in the wake of the Charlie Hebdo attacks. My point was that by making it an ideological priority to deny the Islamic nature of Islamic terrorism, the White House was in fact encouraging people to talk more about terrorism and Islam, not less. It’s a simple fact of human nature that if you deny the obvious, you invite people to debate the obvious. If you don’t believe me, walk into a bar and insist that Michael Jordan didn’t play basketball. Or proclaim that we didn’t win World War II.

jonah_goldberg2

One month later, the answer to my rhetorical question — “Could this argument be any dumber?” — is, on the one hand, absolutely yes. On the other hand, maybe not.

Let’s start with the dumber part. Ever since the Paris attacks, when Muslim terrorists shouted “Allahu akbar” as they slaughtered people in the name of their god, the Obama administration has continued to twist itself into lexicological pretzels, insisting that Islam had nothing to do with those attacks or any others committed by self-declared mujahedeen around the world.

Indeed, the just-concluded White House summit on “Countering Violent Extremism” is a perfect example of the rhetorical and logical cul-de-sac President Obama has crashed into. It was a community-organizing confab dedicated to a problem the community organizer in chief refuses to acknowledge exists. He found himself arguing that Islamic terrorism is an oxymoron, like “jumbo shrimp” or “good flan.”

“No religion is responsible for terrorism,” the president proclaimed, “people are responsible for violence and terrorism.”

Now obviously, there’s some truth to this. We judge people more by their actions than their beliefs. But reasonable people also recognize that our actions often have a causal relationship with our beliefs. This is hardly a controversial — or even debatable — insight. Orthodox Jews don’t avoid bacon because it tastes bad; they do so because they’re kosher. One cannot intelligently discuss why Mother Theresa helped the poor without referring to her faith. And one cannot discuss why the Islamic State burns, rapes and enslaves people without taking their religious beliefs into account.

In an essay for the Wall Street Journal, Secretary of State John Kerry asserts that “violent extremism can’t be justified by resorting to religion. No legitimate religious interpretation teaches adherents to commit unspeakable atrocities” such as those committed by the Islamic State, al-Qaida and other Muslim fanatics. For those who invest in John Kerry supreme religious authority, that statement is unquestionably true. The problem is that very few people take their religious cues from Kerry — or Obama.

The White House repeatedly suggests that terrorism is like crime and that Islamic terrorists simply invoke religion as a convenient mask or marketing ploy. But this is an otherworldly farce, intended to please the ears of those who want to deal with the world as they wish it, not as it is.

The thousands of young men (and women) abandoning the West to join the apocalyptic project of the Islamic State are not doing so simply because they are murderers or petty criminals looking for a convenient excuse. (In the current issue of The Atlantic, Graeme Wood offers a blistering brief on the religious motivations of the Islamic State that should have been required reading at the extremism summit.) No doubt people susceptible to jihadist appeals have their “issues,” but trying to understand jihadists without consulting jihadism is like trying to explain why there are relatively few Amish nuclear engineers without referring to Anabaptism.

By insisting that religious violence is an oxymoron, Obama, Kerry and their spinners are saying that religion can only be a force for good (a view many on the left loudly insist is not the case, at least when it comes to Christians in America). This is obvious nonsense.

And that brings us to the silver lining to Obama’s stubborn refusal to speak plainly about the plainly obvious. As I said at the outset, when you deny a given truth, you force people to explain why the truth is a given. Nearly everyone agrees the earth is round, but if you meet someone who says it’s flat, you’re forced to explain — with facts and logic — why it’s not flat.

Obama’s flat-eartherism on radical Islam is clearly an embarrassing failure in deterring Islamists, but it is forcing serious people to think more deeply about the challenges we face. It’s not the debate Obama wants, but it’s valuable nonetheless.

Jonah Goldberg is a fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and a senior editor of National Review. You can write to him in care of this newspaper or by e-mail at goldbergcolumn@gmail.com, or via Twitter @JonahNRO.

Also See,

Conservatives face bad-faith question of faith

423 thoughts on “Silly Denials Of Islamic Terrorism Bring A Silver Lining”

  6. ed online pharmacy [url=https://edmedscoupon.com/#]where can i get ed pills[/url] reputable overseas online pharmacies

    Reply

  25. best online pharmacy [url=https://pharmrate.shop/#]reputable online pharmacy no prescription[/url] Pharm Rate

    Reply

  33. cheapest ed online [url=https://edmedscoupon.shop/#]ed doctor online[/url] foreign online pharmacy

    Reply

  56. get antibiotics quickly [url=https://antibiotics.cheap/#]antibiotics cheap[/url] over the counter antibiotics

    Reply

  64. stromectol reviews [url=https://stromectol.reviews/#]stromectol tab 3mg[/url] stromectol south africa

    Reply

  70. stromectol reviews [url=https://stromectol.reviews/#]ivermectin price canada[/url] stromectol tablet 3 mg

    Reply

  79. antibiotics cheap [url=https://antibiotics.cheap/#]antibiotics cheap[/url] over the counter antibiotics

    Reply

  88. stromectol 3 mg dosage [url=https://stromectol.reviews/#]stromectol reviews[/url] stromectol reviews

    Reply

  96. semaglutide stomach pain [url=https://semaglutide.life/#]dulaglutide vs semaglutide[/url] rybelsus r1 vs r2

    Reply

  105. antibiotics cheap [url=https://antibiotics.cheap/#]over the counter antibiotics[/url] over the counter antibiotics pills

    Reply

  129. mail order pharmacy india [url=https://indianmedsdelivery.com/#]Indian Meds Delivery[/url] online pharmacies

    Reply

  145. mexico online pharmacy [url=https://mexicanpharm.xyz/#]Mexican Pharm[/url] order antibiotics from mexico

    Reply

  165. cheapest online pharmacy india [url=http://indianmedsdelivery.com/#]Indian Meds Delivery[/url] pharmacy order online

    Reply

  181. worldwide pharmacy online [url=https://onlinepharmfirst.shop/#]Online Pharm First[/url] online pharmacy no rx

    Reply

  204. online pharmacies [url=https://onlinepharmfirst.com/#]Online Pharm First[/url] legal online pharmacies in the us

    Reply

  210. cost of ivermectin 1% cream [url=https://ivermectinfirst.com/#]cost of ivermectin cream[/url] Ivermectin First

    Reply

  218. international pharmacy [url=https://onlinepharmfirst.shop/#]best mail order pharmacy[/url] top online pharmacy

    Reply

  223. Vet Pharm First [url=https://vetpharmfirst.shop/#]Vet Pharm First[/url] Vet Pharm First

    Reply

  251. accidentally took too much semaglutide [url=https://rybelsus.pro/#]weight watchers semaglutide[/url] does semaglutide come in pill form

    Reply

  260. semaglutide reconstitution calculator [url=https://rybelsus.pro/#]se puede tomar rybelsus y metformina juntos[/url] wegovy vs compounded semaglutide

    Reply

  267. Order Viagra 50 mg online [url=https://viagra.onl/#]cheap viagra[/url] Order Viagra 50 mg online

    Reply

  276. can i take rybelsus for weight loss [url=https://rybelsus.pro/#]semaglutide pills[/url] is metformin a semaglutide

    Reply

  287. pusulabet resmi giriş [url=https://bestbetgiris.online/#]pusulabet güncel giriş[/url]

    Reply

  290. cheapest viagra [url=https://viagra.onl/#]Sildenafil Citrate Tablets 100mg[/url] Cheap Viagra 100mg

    Reply

  299. Easy Mex Meds [url=https://easymexmeds.shop/#]mexican pharmacies near me[/url] Easy Mex Meds

    Reply

  302. top 10 pharmacies in india [url=https://easyindiameds.com/#]Easy India Meds[/url] online pharmacy

    Reply

  310. rate canadian pharmacies [url=https://easycanadameds.com/#]Easy Canada Meds[/url] legit canadian pharmacy

    Reply

  313. Easy Canada Meds [url=https://easycanadameds.shop/#]legal canadian pharmacy online[/url] canada rx pharmacy

    Reply

  318. canadian pharmacies online [url=http://easycanadameds.com/#]Easy Canada Meds[/url] Easy Canada Meds

    Reply

  320. canadianpharmacymeds [url=https://easycanadameds.shop/#]the canadian pharmacy[/url] canadianpharmacymeds

    Reply

  323. pharmacy website india [url=http://easyindiameds.com/#]Easy India Meds[/url] п»їinternational drug mart

    Reply

  330. Easy Canada Meds [url=http://easycanadameds.com/#]canadian pharmacy reviews[/url] Easy Canada Meds

    Reply

  334. mexico prescriptions [url=https://easymexmeds.shop/#]mexican pharmacies online[/url] purple pharmacy mexico

    Reply

  337. п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india [url=https://easyindiameds.com/#]Easy India Meds[/url] no script pharmacy

    Reply

  340. best rated canadian pharmacy [url=https://easycanadameds.shop/#]canadian pharmacies comparison[/url] northwest canadian pharmacy

    Reply

  344. meds from mexico [url=http://easymexmeds.com/#]Easy Mex Meds[/url] mexican pharmacies online

    Reply

  346. reputable indian pharmacies [url=https://easyindiameds.com/#]buy prescription drugs from india[/url] legit online pharmacy

    Reply

  349. world pharmacy india [url=https://easyindiameds.com/#]india pharmacy[/url] pharmacy websites

    Reply

  353. precription drugs from canada [url=http://easycanadameds.com/#]pharmacy wholesalers canada[/url] Easy Canada Meds

    Reply

  356. drugs from canada [url=https://easycanadameds.com/#]canadian pharmacies that deliver to the us[/url] Easy Canada Meds

    Reply

  359. Easy Canada Meds [url=https://easycanadameds.shop/#]Easy Canada Meds[/url] Easy Canada Meds

    Reply

  363. Easy Canada Meds [url=https://easycanadameds.shop/#]canadian drugs online[/url] recommended canadian pharmacies

    Reply

  366. online pharmacy in mexico [url=https://easymexmeds.shop/#]Easy Mex Meds[/url] mexican online pharmacy wegovy

    Reply

  369. medication in mexico [url=https://easymexmeds.com/#]Easy Mex Meds[/url] mexican online mail order pharmacy

    Reply

  372. pharmacy website india [url=https://easyindiameds.shop/#]Easy India Meds[/url] worldwide pharmacy

    Reply

  374. Easy Mex Meds [url=http://easymexmeds.com/#]mexican pharmacy ship to usa[/url] mexican online pharmacy

    Reply

  376. Easy Canada Meds [url=https://easycanadameds.com/#]Easy Canada Meds[/url] canadian pharmacy com

    Reply

  378. india online pharmacy [url=https://easyindiameds.com/#]Easy India Meds[/url] medicine online

    Reply

  380. reliable canadian pharmacy reviews [url=http://easycanadameds.com/#]my canadian pharmacy review[/url] online canadian pharmacy

    Reply

  382. cheapest online pharmacy india [url=http://easyindiameds.com/#]Easy India Meds[/url] pharmacy no prescription required

    Reply

  386. Easy Canada Meds [url=http://easycanadameds.com/#]Easy Canada Meds[/url] canada drugs online

    Reply

  411. Generic Tadalafil 20mg price [url=https://cialisvip.com/#]Cialis Vip[/url] Cialis without a doctor prescription

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 

Share this!

Enjoy reading? Share it with your friends!