For Advertising Info, Write.
rwnews@blogads.com
Premium Left blogad
Left Blog Ad

Advertisement
Superman: Truth, Justice And The United Nations Way?
Written By : John Hawkins

In what must be one of the most mediocre comic issues of all-time, the superhero whose slogan used to be “truth, justice, and the American way” has now renounced his American citizenship.

Goyer’s installment, with tense art from Miguel Sepulveda, steals the spotlight in Action Comics No. 900. When Superman drops in on an Iranian protest to stand with demonstrators in an act of nonviolent civil disobedience, the U.S. government takes him to task for acting as an instrument of national policy. Superman responds by renouncing his American citizenship and proclaiming himself a citizen of the universe…

In an age rife with immigration paranoia, it’s refreshing to see an alien refugee tell the United States that it’s as important to him as any other country on Earth — which in turn is as important to Superman as any other planet in the multiverse.

The genius of Superman is that he belongs to everyone, for the dual purposes of peace and protection. He’s above ephemeral geopolitics and nationalist concerns, a universal agent unlike any other found in pop culture.

First of all, Superman renouncing his American citizenship isn’t quite as stupid as Captain America doing it, but it has to be pretty close. What really tops it off, however, is a comic book about a superhero with essentially unlimited powers standing with citizens who’re being murdered in the streets in an act of “nonviolent civil disobedience.” Here’s an indestructible super human who can lift anything, melt tanks with his eyes, and blow military jets out of the sky, and he’s playing Gandhi. What must the Iranian protestors think? Oh boy, Superman is here and he’s….wait, he’s standing around? Ehr….and you’re leaving when the protest is over? Thanks…sort of, well, not really.”

PS #1: Let me go full nerd on you and point this out: It would be impossible for someone like Superman to get involved in geopolitics and remain a good guy long term. There are dozens of governments across the planet abusing and murdering their people on a daily basis. If Superman is going to start getting involved when it happens, then he’s setting himself up as global judge, jury, and inevitably, an executioner — because that’s what it would take to stop some of these governments from raping, robbing, and butchering their populaces. Then, when Superman couldn’t be everywhere at once, the next step would either be giving up or building his own army to overthrow governments and enforce his moral code on other nations. By that point, every government in the world would be nervous enough to try to develop weapons powerful enough to kill Superman for their own defense.

0
  • Anonymous

    Whatever. The comic industry no longer exists in any meaningful way. DC and Marvel are both owned by gigantic media companies (Time Warner and Disney) that are more concerned with foreign marketing than the intellectual property. If turning Superman into an advocate for illegal immigration puts a few more butts in seats overseas when the next crappy movie comes out, it’s a done deal. Sucks if you’re a fan, but comic heroes have about as much artistic and intellectual integrity as Hannah Montana now.

    • Anonymous

      As a life-long fanboy it pains me to say that your analysis is absolutely spot on, sir.
      Siegel and Shuster must be spinning in their graves.

    • http://www.vega.com Vega – The Smart, Sexy Liberal

      Right on, boax. X-men has been in shambles for years.

      They simply do not have great writers anymore, because great writers do not want to make shit money working for a multi-billion dollar corp.

      It was different when Marvel was independent. There was passion in writers.

      Do yourselves a favor and buy back issues.

    • http://www.vega.com Vega – The Smart, Sexy Liberal

      Right on, boax. X-men has been in shambles for years.

      They simply do not have great writers anymore, because great writers do not want to make shit money working for a multi-billion dollar corp.

      It was different when Marvel was independent. There was passion in writers.

      Do yourselves a favor and buy back issues.

    • http://www.vega.com Vega – The Smart, Sexy Liberal

      Right on, boax. X-men has been in shambles for years.

      They simply do not have great writers anymore, because great writers do not want to make shit money working for a multi-billion dollar corp.

      It was different when Marvel was independent. There was passion in writers.

      Do yourselves a favor and buy back issues.

    • http://www.vega.com Vega – The Smart, Sexy Liberal

      Right on, boax. X-men has been in shambles for years.

      They simply do not have great writers anymore, because great writers do not want to make shit money working for a multi-billion dollar corp.

      It was different when Marvel was independent. There was passion in writers.

      Do yourselves a favor and buy back issues.

  • Anonymous

    If the Iranians shoot at the peaceful protestors (with Superman in the group) the number of bullets bouncing off of the man of steel and hitting his protestor friends has to go up.

    If he wants peaceful he should simply grab the leadership of Iran and fly them off to an island somewhere.

  • Anonymous

    I’m surprised Superman is still around at all for:
    There is no place for vigilantism within the New World Order.
    Much like BHO he has an issue with producing a birth certificate.

  • Martin Hale

    I’m working on a theory that politics is either the most pernicious virus known to man, or it’s the ubiquitous ‘grey goo’ that the futurists get their panties in a bunch about. Or maybe it’s like copier toner.

    In any case it gets everywhere, into everything and is virtually impossible to get rid of without destroying the object into which it’s gotten.

    My alternate theory is that politics is the anti-Christ come to bring us to our knees..

    Not that I particularly care about comics, but honestly, does politics have to pop up in everything these days?

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_YWXM6Q6QGELGTT334IQMWB774Q David

      If you are a Leftist, then yes, politics has to be in everything.

      • Martin Hale

        What’s that stupid thing they say (I know, I know, they say a lot of stupid things)? Oh yeah, “the personal is the political”.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_YWXM6Q6QGELGTT334IQMWB774Q David

      If you are a Leftist, then yes, politics has to be in everything.

  • Martin Hale

    I’m working on a theory that politics is either the most pernicious virus known to man, or it’s the ubiquitous ‘grey goo’ that the futurists get their panties in a bunch about. Or maybe it’s like copier toner.

    In any case it gets everywhere, into everything and is virtually impossible to get rid of without destroying the object into which it’s gotten.

    My alternate theory is that politics is the anti-Christ come to bring us to our knees..

    Not that I particularly care about comics, but honestly, does politics have to pop up in everything these days?

  • Martin Hale

    I’m working on a theory that politics is either the most pernicious virus known to man, or it’s the ubiquitous ‘grey goo’ that the futurists get their panties in a bunch about. Or maybe it’s like copier toner.

    In any case it gets everywhere, into everything and is virtually impossible to get rid of without destroying the object into which it’s gotten.

    My alternate theory is that politics is the anti-Christ come to bring us to our knees..

    Not that I particularly care about comics, but honestly, does politics have to pop up in everything these days?

  • Anonymous

    Isn’t Obama the POTUS that turned his back while Iranians were being killed int he streets opposing the regime?

    Who’d have thought Obama could run off Superman while embracing 25,000,000 illegal criminal aliens here in the US. He really is The One.

  • Anonymous

    Maybe instead of standing around he could have saved a few women from being stoned to death. Since he was in the area.

  • Anonymous

    “In an age rife with immigration paranoia”

    Legit concerns =! paranoia.
    immigration =! illegal immigration

  • Anonymous

    “In an age rife with immigration paranoia”

    Legit concerns =! paranoia.
    immigration =! illegal immigration

  • Anonymous

    You know, the more I think about this decision by DC, the more angry I’m getting…
    This is a real travesty. If it were up to me, which it isn’t, the editor(s) who signed off on this would be fired and blacklisted from working in the comic industry. These people have been entrusted with the stewardship of iconic characters (I’m not just talking about Supes) who have been ingrained in American pop culture since the late 30s… and this is what they do with them? They turn around and totally disregard/disrespect the ideals and visions of the characters’ creators and for what? To make these icons fit their own personal and political belief system? That is petty, and pretentious, and downright shameful.
    I am truly disgusted with the state of things in the modern comic world. Where is today’s writer/editors’ sense of principle? Their respect for tradition? These characters and their adventures which they have inherited are part of American folklore. They teach lessons about oldfashioned ideals such as duty, determination, selflessness and honor; values that should be cherished and celebrated, not shunned as if they’re embarrassing, outdated concepts.
    *sigh* It turns my stomach to think that creative control over these esteemed archetypes has been given over to such paltry, short-sighted people.
    (/rant)

  • Anonymous

    You know, the more I think about this decision by DC, the more angry I’m getting…
    This is a real travesty. If it were up to me, which it isn’t, the editor(s) who signed off on this would be fired and blacklisted from working in the comic industry. These people have been entrusted with the stewardship of iconic characters (I’m not just talking about Supes) who have been ingrained in American pop culture since the late 30s… and this is what they do with them? They turn around and totally disregard/disrespect the ideals and visions of the characters’ creators and for what? To make these icons fit their own personal and political belief system? That is petty, and pretentious, and downright shameful.
    I am truly disgusted with the state of things in the modern comic world. Where is today’s writer/editors’ sense of principle? Their respect for tradition? These characters and their adventures which they have inherited are part of American folklore. They teach lessons about oldfashioned ideals such as duty, determination, selflessness and honor; values that should be cherished and celebrated, not shunned as if they’re embarrassing, outdated concepts.
    *sigh* It turns my stomach to think that creative control over these esteemed archetypes has been given over to such paltry, short-sighted people.
    (/rant)

    • Martin Hale

      GOB – maybe you know the answer to this. Has Superman ever really been an American? I mean he did immigrate here from somewhere else, and I don’t recall him ever becoming a citizen – but I’m not all that up on the story lines.

      Am I mistaken in thinking that he’s the ultimate illegal alien?

      • Anonymous

        I’ve heard that question before… and let me preface my answer by admitting that I’m not a huge Superman fan, but I respect the mythology and legacy of the franchise. With that said…
        Yes, Kal El or Clark Kent is an American citizen. And yes, the Kents did legally adopt him:
        http://supermanica.superman.nu/wiki/index.php/Jonathan_and_Martha_Kent

      • Anonymous

        I’ve heard that question before… and let me preface my answer by admitting that I’m not a huge Superman fan, but I respect the mythology and legacy of the franchise. With that said…
        Yes, Kal El or Clark Kent is an American citizen. And yes, the Kents did legally adopt him:
        http://supermanica.superman.nu/wiki/index.php/Jonathan_and_Martha_Kent

        • http://www.vega.com Vega – The Smart, Sexy Liberal

          Yes, GOB is correct. That’s not the original, original story, but that is the official canon.

        • http://www.vega.com Vega – The Smart, Sexy Liberal

          Yes, GOB is correct. That’s not the original, original story, but that is the official canon.

      • Anonymous

        I’ve heard that question before… and let me preface my answer by admitting that I’m not a huge Superman fan, but I respect the mythology and legacy of the franchise. With that said…
        Yes, Kal El or Clark Kent is an American citizen. And yes, the Kents did legally adopt him:
        http://supermanica.superman.nu/wiki/index.php/Jonathan_and_Martha_Kent

      • Anonymous

        I’ve heard that question before… and let me preface my answer by admitting that I’m not a huge Superman fan, but I respect the mythology and legacy of the franchise. With that said…
        Yes, Kal El or Clark Kent is an American citizen. And yes, the Kents did legally adopt him:
        http://supermanica.superman.nu/wiki/index.php/Jonathan_and_Martha_Kent

  • Anonymous

    OMG thousands of pimply faced basement dwellers wont know what democracy is…

    • Anonymous

      Huh? Why are you bringing up Daily Kos?

    • Anonymous

      Huh? Why are you bringing up Daily Kos?

      • Anonymous

        First, Superman isn’t real. Sorry. He’s a fictitious character. Martin Luther King was real. One is a new story line, the other is rewriting history.

        Second, Name me one comic super hero that has had a consistent character development (alternate worlds, alternate realities). Characters die and miraculously come back to life (like Superman). Characters go from good guy to bad guy and back again. Hero to heel.

        Third, these story lines simply reflect the period that they are written in to satisfy their audience and if that story line goes too far, the publisher simply reinvents that character again.

        This is reminiscent of Marvels Civil War addressing the issues of that time. Some people liked where their favorite character landed philosophically, others not so much.

        For all the squawking about whats really important right now Johns wandered way off the path on this one.

      • Anonymous

        First, Superman isn’t real. Sorry. He’s a fictitious character. Martin Luther King was real. One is a new story line, the other is rewriting history.

        Second, Name me one comic super hero that has had a consistent character development (alternate worlds, alternate realities). Characters die and miraculously come back to life (like Superman). Characters go from good guy to bad guy and back again. Hero to heel.

        Third, these story lines simply reflect the period that they are written in to satisfy their audience and if that story line goes too far, the publisher simply reinvents that character again.

        This is reminiscent of Marvels Civil War addressing the issues of that time. Some people liked where their favorite character landed philosophically, others not so much.

        For all the squawking about whats really important right now Johns wandered way off the path on this one.

      • Anonymous

        Someone needs to make a comic book about a reincarnated Karl Marx who has learned the error of his ways (after discussing such matters with saint Reagan in heaven) and now is tasked with wiping out the scourge of socialism here on earth before he can finally atone for the millions of murders carried out in his name.

        It would be no less ludicrous than this story, and at least it would have a good moral.

      • Anonymous

        GOB, Superman is a fictional character, MLK was not.

    • Anonymous

      Huh? Why are you bringing up Daily Kos?

    • Anonymous

      Huh? Why are you bringing up Daily Kos?

  • Anonymous

    OMG thousands of pimply faced basement dwellers wont know what democracy is…

  • Anonymous

    OMG thousands of pimply faced basement dwellers wont know what democracy is…

  • http://www.wordaroundthenet.com Christopher Taylor

    How on earth would Superman be a citizen anyway? Did he take the test or something? He wasn’t born in the country, and even if he had been, he has a secret identity and “Superman” isn’t part of any country. This is just ludicrous.

  • http://www.wordaroundthenet.com Christopher Taylor

    How on earth would Superman be a citizen anyway? Did he take the test or something? He wasn’t born in the country, and even if he had been, he has a secret identity and “Superman” isn’t part of any country. This is just ludicrous.

    • Anonymous

      Upon rescuing him from his crashed ship, the Kents turned young Kal-El over to an orphanage, who assumed that he was an American citizen of unknown parentage. The Kents then filled out the proper paperwork to adopt him and were allowed to do so. THAT is how he’s a citizen; bureaucracy.

    • Anonymous

      Upon rescuing him from his crashed ship, the Kents turned young Kal-El over to an orphanage, who assumed that he was an American citizen of unknown parentage. The Kents then filled out the proper paperwork to adopt him and were allowed to do so. THAT is how he’s a citizen; bureaucracy.

      • http://www.vega.com Vega – The Smart, Sexy Liberal

        So it was under false pretenses.

        I want to see his birth certificate.

        • Anonymous

          LMAO

        • Anonymous

          LMAO

        • Anonymous

          LMAO

        • Anonymous

          LMAO

        • Anonymous

          Sure, when he runs for president.

    • Anonymous

      Upon rescuing him from his crashed ship, the Kents turned young Kal-El over to an orphanage, who assumed that he was an American citizen of unknown parentage. The Kents then filled out the proper paperwork to adopt him and were allowed to do so. THAT is how he’s a citizen; bureaucracy.

    • Anonymous

      Upon rescuing him from his crashed ship, the Kents turned young Kal-El over to an orphanage, who assumed that he was an American citizen of unknown parentage. The Kents then filled out the proper paperwork to adopt him and were allowed to do so. THAT is how he’s a citizen; bureaucracy.

  • Anonymous

    I will say, if they were actually treating this issue for what they’re saying they are, then this might be a fairly interesting issue to discuss.
    What WOULD the geopolitical consequences of someone like Superman be? To what extent could his actions be taken as American foreign policy? Is it right that this should be so?

    But, just like the whole Civil War thing a few years back, they’re not really looking to discuss this issue at hand. Civil War could have been super interesting – to what extent are these superheroes – vigilantes – subject to the people that they’re supposed to protect? Is it right that they should be able to carry on their anonymous vigilantism? But instead of actually discussing that they just turned it into one big “OMG evil America Republican government invasion of privacy etc. etc.”

    I assume the same thing will happen here. Who wants to read interesting philosophical “what-ifs” when we can instead bash America?

  • Pingback: Superman: Truth, Justice And The United Nations Way? | NewsReal Blog

  • Pingback: Superman: Truth, Justice And The United Nations Way? | News Patriot

  • Pingback: Superman: Truth, Justice And The United Nations Way? | Blog on Fitness-Jewelry

  • Anonymous

    Its a comic book, you know fiction, fantasy. Get a grip.

  • http://twitter.com/JesseMXGangl Jesse Gangl

    This is what I posted on another site on this issue:

    I don’t comprehend this oft-repeated here notion that Superman as an American doesn’t make sense. He spent the entirety of his formative years on a farm in small-town America living an unremarkable rural middle class lifestyle. To say that he is just as much Indonesian, Liberian, or Portuguese as he is American is nonsensical in the extreme. Not to mention the fact that it’s long been established that Superman is the inverse of Batman in that Superman is just a name people call him. To the man himself, he’s always and simply Clark Kent from Smallville. He honors his home planet and the nobility of his birth parents, but he is, at heart, the product of American values inculcated in an American small town by American friends and adoptive family.

    The international element to Superman has always been to represent the good will and charity of the American people regardless of, and distinct from, the elected officials in power. Superman served as a metaphorical extension of the American peoples’ vast voluntary capacity for charity and compassion towards those who, for one reason or another, have fallen on hard times or who are not as fortunate as we (Americans) are. This should be, and has been, decisively divorced from any actions perpetrated by the American government itself. Hell, the whole point of books like Red Son or True Brit for that matter was to show that Superman would be a far different person if his ship had landed somewhere else on Earth. These are meant to contrast with the distinct and iconic Superman who is the way he is, all other things being equal, precisely because he landed in America.

    To encapsulate this misreading and self-deception about Superman “American-ness,” I offer the following example. I’m personally a huge Tolkien fan and have studied him and his work at the bachelor and master’s level. So much of what he wrote resounds with me profoundly and deeply, but you know what? I fully realize and accept that nothing in Middle Earth is about America or Americans. It’s about England and the Anglo-Saxon Germanic peoples that settled in the British Isles and from whom Tolkien traced his lineage. Just because Tolkien’s works appeal to me and have a universal, even international quality does NOT mean I would ever selfishly trivialize those works by, say, claiming that they’re not intrinsically English or that they belong equally to me as an American. I would also especially take offense at Aragorn showing up at the UN to undermine Gondorian sovereignty because the way of the Dunedain and the wisdom of the elves are just “not enough anymore.” This is a petty attempt at being topical and globalist at the expense the contemporary world’s favorite star-spangled punching bag, and I really wish people (my fellow Americans in particular) could see this as the insulting tripe that it is. Between this and the revisionism of the G.I. Joe movie, I just don’t understand why people have such a problem if Americans are anything but ashamed of their nationality.

  • http://twitter.com/JesseMXGangl Jesse Gangl

    This is what I posted on another site on this issue:

    I don’t comprehend this oft-repeated here notion that Superman as an American doesn’t make sense. He spent the entirety of his formative years on a farm in small-town America living an unremarkable rural middle class lifestyle. To say that he is just as much Indonesian, Liberian, or Portuguese as he is American is nonsensical in the extreme. Not to mention the fact that it’s long been established that Superman is the inverse of Batman in that Superman is just a name people call him. To the man himself, he’s always and simply Clark Kent from Smallville. He honors his home planet and the nobility of his birth parents, but he is, at heart, the product of American values inculcated in an American small town by American friends and adoptive family.

    The international element to Superman has always been to represent the good will and charity of the American people regardless of, and distinct from, the elected officials in power. Superman served as a metaphorical extension of the American peoples’ vast voluntary capacity for charity and compassion towards those who, for one reason or another, have fallen on hard times or who are not as fortunate as we (Americans) are. This should be, and has been, decisively divorced from any actions perpetrated by the American government itself. Hell, the whole point of books like Red Son or True Brit for that matter was to show that Superman would be a far different person if his ship had landed somewhere else on Earth. These are meant to contrast with the distinct and iconic Superman who is the way he is, all other things being equal, precisely because he landed in America.

    To encapsulate this misreading and self-deception about Superman “American-ness,” I offer the following example. I’m personally a huge Tolkien fan and have studied him and his work at the bachelor and master’s level. So much of what he wrote resounds with me profoundly and deeply, but you know what? I fully realize and accept that nothing in Middle Earth is about America or Americans. It’s about England and the Anglo-Saxon Germanic peoples that settled in the British Isles and from whom Tolkien traced his lineage. Just because Tolkien’s works appeal to me and have a universal, even international quality does NOT mean I would ever selfishly trivialize those works by, say, claiming that they’re not intrinsically English or that they belong equally to me as an American. I would also especially take offense at Aragorn showing up at the UN to undermine Gondorian sovereignty because the way of the Dunedain and the wisdom of the elves are just “not enough anymore.” This is a petty attempt at being topical and globalist at the expense the contemporary world’s favorite star-spangled punching bag, and I really wish people (my fellow Americans in particular) could see this as the insulting tripe that it is. Between this and the revisionism of the G.I. Joe movie, I just don’t understand why people have such a problem if Americans are anything but ashamed of their nationality.

  • Pingback: Superman, Citizen of the World. Right’s Head Explodes? « Graphic Policy

  • http://www.facebook.com/joseph.veca Joseph Veca

    Considering that this is Dhimmi Comics, who recreated Wonder Women’s costume as to make it less offensive to Muslims, this move comes as a surprise to anyone?

  • http://www.facebook.com/joseph.veca Joseph Veca

    Considering that this is Dhimmi Comics, who recreated Wonder Women’s costume as to make it less offensive to Muslims, this move comes as a surprise to anyone?

  • http://www.facebook.com/joseph.veca Joseph Veca

    Considering that this is Dhimmi Comics, who recreated Wonder Women’s costume as to make it less offensive to Muslims, this move comes as a surprise to anyone?

  • Pingback: PC Comics: Superman Renounces America!

  • Pingback: PC Comics: Superman Renounces America! | NewsReal Blog

  • Pingback: PC Comics: Superman Renounces America! | Blog on Fitness-Jewelry

Advertisement
Featured Video

Who Is Brett Kimberlin?

php developer india
Premium Right Ads
Blogads Right
Previous Features

Ads

The Best Quotes From “Ten Prayers God Always Says Yes To”
Hey Lady Gaga, Kids Have a Time-Tested Answer for Bullies: Punch Them in the Mouth
Seven Differences Between Winners And Losers
The Problem With The Occupy Wall Street Generation
The 20 Most Influential Black Republicans
Talking With Chuck D. From Public Enemy About Farrakhan, Air America’s Failure, And Open Borders
Advertisement
User Info